Techniques of Trust

Let It Happen


Stop Trying to Be a Good Musician


Permission to Fail

 

Articles from Flute Talk Magazine

Stop Trying To Be A Good Musician


When I play difficult Passages at a fast tempo, my fingers become tense, While practicing at home I struggle over measures cluttered with black notes and when it is time to play them, besides not inhaling enough air, I stiffen my fingers. Rehearsing the same piece with an ensemble, I panic when I see the same spot and tense up further. By contrast, every time I bring the passage to my lesson and ask for help, the problem is not so bad. Why can I play it in my lesson but tense up when the pressure is on?


It is interesting that when you ask for help in your lesson, the problem of tension does not persist, yet in performance when you do not want to be tense, the problem gets in your way. This suggests that when you are trying to play correctly, it doesn't works, but when you are aware of the problem and show it to your teacher, the problem disappears. In a lesson situation, your goal is to explore the tension, not try to make it go away. When we increase our awareness or pay attention to something to discover what is happening, we are no longer trying to control it or make it go away. The result is the correction of the problem itself, which is the key.


Trying too hard to accomplish anything usually creates the opposite result; because trying produces tension it also reduces the player's senses of sight, hearing, and feeling. Tensing the muscles in your fingers while keeping your joints flexible would be difficult. If you can feel movement in your hands, you cannot be tense.


This is an inner game skill of concentration known as non-judgmental awareness. If you notice you are playing bad notes, have poor intonation or sloppy rhythm, you are no longer in a non judgmental awareness mode. In fact, you may feel guilty, depressed, anxious, or tense. Your challenge is to monitor what is happening without judging it as good or bad. A non judgmental awareness instruction asks you to notice only the difference between your softest and loudest sounds. A judgmental instruction asks you to play with good dynamics and make sure the forte is right and doesn't blast. Although the second instruction has meaning, it is opinionated and polluted with rights, wrongs, and won't help the player hear what is happening.


Awareness is the antithesis of trying, but perhaps also the remedy for not trying. The next time you find yourself in a trying mode, playing fast passages, running out of breath, or searching for car keys, put yourself in an awareness mode. For the fast pass sages, become aware of which fingers feel the most tense and which notes are not accurate, For breath support, monitor the way you distribute your air flow. For locating car keys, think about where you were the last time you had them in your hands. These awareness exercises will put you in touch with your movements rather than fix the problem. When you are in touch with what you are doing, you can discover what you need to do to play as you intend.


When you wanted to show your teacher the problematic passage, you didn't make mistakes. The game changed from trying to make the problem go away to making the teacher aware of what you wanted to change. During a lesson you feel more safe to have a problem because someone will help you deal with it. When you stop trying to play accurately to make the teacher aware, you move into an awareness state. When you are confronted with a similar fast passage in an ensemble, rather than trying to play it accurately, listen to the speed of your notes compared to others playing the same rhythms. This will allow you to become aware of what is happening with the tempo and with this feedback, play in time with everyone else.


The first step to exploring these concepts is to become aware of when you are trying and then rid yourself of judgment, tension, and worry over accuracy. Replace this with non judgmental awareness of what you see, hear, or feel. Enjoy the next step without trying.

 
© Copyright Barry Green 2005